Cruisin’ Regent Street

Screen Shot 2015-04-09 at 2.14.49 PM
Regent Street today, specifically the curved part heading towards Piccadilly Circus

I was tasked with looking into Regent Street in London, which is mentioned in A Scandal in Bohemia. Here is the passage from the story that mentions Regent Street, and it entails Holmes describing Irene Adlers’ future husband:

 “He was in the house about half an hour, and I could catch glimpses of him in the windows of the sitting-room, pacing up and down, talking excitedly, and waving his arms. Of her I could see nothing. Presently he emerged, looking even more flurried than before. As he stepped up to the cab, he pulled a gold watch from his pocket and looked at it earnestly, ‘Drive like the devil,’ he shouted, ‘first to Gross & Hankey’s in Regent Street, and then to the Church of St. Monica in the Edgeware Road. Half a guinea if you do it in twenty minutes!’

According to the Conan Doyle Encyclopedia, Gross & Hankey’s was probably a jewelry shop, although it was fictitious. Mr. Norton hurried there before going to the church to secure the wedding bands. After researching the Regent Street area, I focused on the section of the street that curves, heading into Piccadilly Circus. Today, this is a very upscale shopping district, and there is an Underground station at Piccadilly Circus. (Note: In this context, a circus, from the Latin word meaning “circle”, is a round open space at a street junction)

Screen Shot 2015-04-08 at 4.03.15 PM
Victorian Google Map of the Regent Street and Piccadilly Circus area
Screen Shot 2015-04-08 at 4.04.20 PM
Current Google Map of Regent Street leading into Piccadilly Circus. Note several upscale shops on Regent in this area today.
Screen Shot 2015-04-09 at 1.07.30 PM
Using http://www.locatinglondon.org, a 1746 map shows Piccadilly, but Regent Street doesn’t exist yet. “The Hay Market” on the right corresponds to the lower part of the future Regent Street.

Although the jewelry shop was fictional, Booths’ map shows red and yellow which indicate the upper end of income. It can be established that the Regent Street/Piccadilly Circus area has been wealthy for over a century, at least.

Screen Shot 2015-04-08 at 4.10.28 PM
Charles Booth Map of Regent by Piccadilly Circus

Finally, British History Online provides an even deeper glimpse into the history of Regent Street. This website reinforced the facts that I already knew; the commercial aspects and the wealth of the area were well established. However, I also discovered when Regent Street was designed and built (1813), why it was named as it was, and the architect behind the buildings (John Nash).

The long vista of Regent Street, as seen from the Quadrant, is very fine, exhibiting, as it does, a remarkable variety of architectural features. It was erected principally from the designs of Mr. John Nash, who deserves to be remembered as the author of this great metropolitan improvement; and it was named from the architect’s patron, the PrinceRegent. The expenditure of the Office of Woods and Forests in its construction was a little in excess of a million and a half. Of course, being a thoroughfare of so recent a date, having been commenced in 1813, Regent Street has scarcely a back history for us to record here, like Pall Mall and St. James’s Street. It belongs to “new,” and not to “old” London.

In his design for Regent Street, Nash adopted the idea of uniting several dwellings into a façade, so as to preserve a degree of continuity essential to architectural importance; and it cannot be denied that he has produced a varied succession of architectural scenery, the effect of which is picturesque and imposing, superior to that of any other portion of the then existing metropolis, and far preferable to the naked brick walls at that time universally forming the sides of our streets.

Edgware Road

Screen Shot 2015-04-07 at 8.45.47 PM

Screen Shot 2015-04-07 at 8.48.02 PM

In “A Scandal in Bohemia,” Sir Arthur Conan Doyle briefly refers to Edgware Road in regards to the Church of St. Monica where Irene Adler marries Godfrey Norton.  Based on the Wikipedia article, “Edgware Road is a major road through north-west London, starting at Marble Arch in the City of Westminster (south end) and running north-west to Edgware in the London Borough of Barnet.”

Screen Shot 2015-04-08 at 2.16.50 PM

The first source that I used in order to learn more about this area was the “Charles Booth Online Archive” in order to view what the economic status was like during the time that the Sherlock Holmes stories were written.  Based on this archive, I discovered that in this particular area the colors that are present on the map are mainly red and yellow.  Based on the legend of the Charles Booth Online Archive, the red represents the middle class and well-to-do people and the yellow represents the upper-classes and very wealthy.  This particular detail about the area correlates with “A Scandal in Bohemia” because Irene Adler is a well-known American opera singer and in the story, she is going to marry a very well-to-do lawyer named Godfrey Norton, therefore, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle chooses this place from the London area in order to really show what Edgware Road was like because Church of St. Monica is a very elegant church.

The second source that I used to learn more about this area was “Locating London’s Past” in order to view how much criminal activity was occurring in this particular area of London when the Sherlock Holmes stories were written. Based on “Locating London’s Past,” between 1800-1819 there were 21 instances of criminal activity on Edgware Road; 21 is a relatively low number.  Therefore, this particular detail about the area relates to “A Scandal in Bohemia” because when Irene Adler, Godfrey Norton, and Sherlock Holmes are on Edgware Road, it is not because a crime was committed, but rather for a wedding.  Moreover, this further emphasizes the daily activity that took place on this particular road, one of which was not much crime.

The third source that I used to learn more about Edgware Road was “The Historical Eye” in order to view what was located in that area when the Sherlock Holmes stories were written.  According to “The Historical Eye”,  the Marble Arch stood in front of the entrance leading to Buckingham Palace, “bearing the Royal banner of England.”  Moreover, the Marble Arch is a very important landmark near Edgware Road.  Therefore, this particular detail correlates to Edgware Road in “A Scandal in Bohemia” because the Marble Arch is a very important and ravishing landmark which shows the wealth of the area and it is understandable why Irene Adler and Godfrey Norton get married at the church on Edgware Road because they are wealthy and they want to have a perfect and prosperous setting.  Below is a screenshot of the Marble Arch circa 1896 from “The Historical Eye”.

Screen Shot 2015-04-08 at 11.31.30 PM

Mapping Holmes Project by Kristen Warfield

The street that I chose for my mapping project was Brixton Road from “The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle.”

As we had read in class, the basis of this story investigates the theft of a jewel, a “blue carbuncle.” Holmes and Watson find the missing jewel due to an honest gentleman that realizes it was hidden in the neck of a goose he was going to make for dinner. Our detectives then went out to find the source of the goose, which they figured out were supplied by a woman named Mrs. Oakshott – a resident of Brixton Road in London!

Here’s a screenshot from the Victorian Google Map of my location (right).

Screen Shot 2015-04-07 at 8.43.59 PM

To learn about the past crimes involving this road, I set off to the Old Bailey archive of London’s Central Criminal Court. I really liked using this database because it provides an in-depth look into public documents of the past.

There were 10 entries involving Brixton Road, mostly involving grand larceny, theft and burglary – but I did come across two rather peculiar findings… two instances of animal theft! Upon looking into these cases more, one particular case of a shepherd stealing someone’s sheep and butchering them lead me to believe that this could possibly be a source of inspiration to the story due to the seemingly rural nature of the area.

In the story, the man who had the jewel (Ryder) had traveled to his sister (Mrs. Oakshott)’s house on Brixton Road to “pick out his Christmas goose.” He picked a goose and shoved the jewel down it’s throat, both relating the case of animal theft found in the Old Bailey archive – he put an item of theft, essentially, into an animal! By learning of the past crime documented in the area, the fictional occurence in the Holmes story does not seem out of character at all for the road.

Now onto another aspect of my research: Charles Booth’s Poverty Map. By plugging in Brixton Road, I learned that the road proper was generally a middle class, “well-to-do” population. However, when we look at the upper left of my screenshot of the data, we see that there is a small region that is indeed classified as “very poor” and “poor.”

Brixton Road is the large road on the right hand side of the image encased in red coloring.
Brixton Road is the large road on the right hand side of the image encased in red coloring.

I thought that it was rather interesting for such a huge gap in income over what essentially is just a block worth of space. I continued to do some further research to figure out why this may be on British History Online.

According to this database, a various number of estates resided on Brixton Road : most of which were parcels of land or homes inherited from other seemingly wealthy family members. I chose to investigate even further by reading an entry about a specific family’s role in the development of the road.

The Angell Estate had been passed down through family members since the near 17th century on and some family members inherited acres upon acres of land on Brixton Road. From reviewing the materials, I learned that this land later included areas for farming.

Though farmers are wrongly stereotyped as not the wealthiest of individuals, it may very well be possible that the industry that brought this area it’s status of wealth was in fact farming. Based off of the evidence that I have found about the amount of estates on this road, I can conclude that this was somewhat of a small plantation area, and the small portion of the “poor-very poor” classification area next to the road could possibly be where some of less-wealthy workers of these estates or plantations lived.

Sources:
Charles Booth Online Archive (http://booth.lse.ac.uk/, 08 April 2015) 1898-99 Map, search:”Brixton Road.”
Old Bailey Proceedings Online (www.oldbaileyonline.org, version 7.2, 08 April 2015), October 1807, trial of JOHN KING , alias BENJAMIN GIBBS
‘Brixton: The Angell estate.’ Survey of London: Volume 26, Lambeth: Southern Area. Ed. F H W Sheppard. London: London County Council, 1956. 125-131. British History Online. Web. 2 April 2015.

Mapping Holmes

For this assignment, I decided to focus on Fenchurch Street, a location that was mentioned in the Sherlock Holmes story A Case Of Identity. In the story, Fenchurch Street is the location of Miss Sutherland’s step-father’s place of business. Located just around the block from here is Miss Sutherland’s fiancee’s home on Leadenhall Street, which (SPOILER ALERT) turns out to be Miss Sutherland’s step-father. You can see a picture of Fenchurch Street on a map I got from Victorian Google Maps below:

Screen shot 2015-04-07 at 7.23.48 PM

When I looked at the Charles Booth Online Archive, I found out that during the 19th century Fenchurch Street was a very poor area, as you can see on the map and color guide below. The black and blues show that people of the lowest classes lived in this area. This relates back to the Holmes story because Mr. Windibank, Miss Sutherland’s step-father, tried to pose as another man to make Miss Sutherland fall in love with him so he could eventually marry her and take all her money. Mr. Windibank’s place of business was also located just around the block from Fenchurch Street on Leadenhall Street. This area was a good location for Arthur Conan Doyle to put both of Mr. Windibank’s identities in because it shows that he has very little money. If he lived and worked in a different area it wouldn’t make as much sense to the story.

Screen shot 2015-04-07 at 8.02.32 PMScreen shot 2015-04-07 at 8.02.48 PM

On the Old Bailey Archive, I did a search on my location and found a list of the crimes committed throughout the 19th century. Most of these crimes listed were for all things theft related, like grand larceny, shoplifting, pickpocketing, and even a couple of theft related murders. When I looked at the Locating London website, I found similar results. Then I decided to look at the British History Online website. When I searched my location on there, I found many texts involving businesses and factories, where I learned that this area held many businesses and industries and probably had many jobs that people of the working class had. I’m not saying that poor people were more likely to be criminals, but in order to survive and support their families people of the lower classes needed to do what they could, and theft was probably a last resort option for them to get necessities.

DeFranco_Mapping Holmes Assignment

I chose to focus on Leadenhall Street from the Sherlock Holmes story, A Case of Identity for this mapping/research assignment. This image is screen-shotted from the Victorian Google Maps website. Leadenhall Street is the thick, long street running horizontal through the image.

Screen shot 2015-04-07 at 3.37.50 PM

On the Old Bailey Archive I did a search of Leadenhall Street in the 1800s and found man phrases that much of what came up seemed business related, as if Leadenhall was a bustling, though not incredibly wealthy, business district with many places of employment and local businesses. Here are some examples of what I found that lead me to make this conclusion:

-“…I am a clerk at the post office, 114, Leadenhall Street…”
-“…Holder Brothers, Ship brokers, 146, Leadenhall Street…”
-“…he was an advertising agent in Leadenhall Street…”
-“…I am a printer, of 18, Leadenhall Market…”
-“…I am a tea importer, of 158, Leadenhall Street…” etc.

On the Charles Booth Online Archive I searched for the Street and came up with the following 1898-99 map.

Screen shot 2015-04-07 at 4.05.38 PM Screen shot 2015-04-07 at 4.06.23 PM

According to the legend, the coloring of the map showing the surrounding areas of Leadenhall Street indicate that this was not a wealthy area. It seems that most of this area (the light blue range) is poor and some (the dark blue) indicates very poor areas. I can’t really tell if there are actually dark blue areas or if it’s just light blues layered on top of each other making certain spots look darker. Anyway, from this information and what I previously discovered about the many businesses along Leadenhall Street, it seems that it was a very working class area where people just barely managed to scrape buy and support their families and provide the necessities. Maybe there aren’t quite and “very poor” dark blue areas because there are lots of small local jobs in the area so people are not in the range of “chronic want.”

On the Locating London website, I did a search of Leadenhall Street to discover what typed of crime were reported in this area in the early 1800s. What I found were that all of the offenses were related to theft: pickpocketing, grand larceny, coining offenses, theft from a specified place, shoplifting, highway robbery, etc. I supposed this makes sense if the area was full of businesses and people just barely making it by. I’m not associating the poor with the crime, but these people were, in some way, wanting (indicated by the map showing wealth), and this could lead to theft.

Topic Modeling

The ten topics I have are murder, travel, house, description, religion, divorce, schedule, job, investigation, and performance. While graphing the topics on google fusion tables I put topics like murder and investigation together in one chart to show the correlations between the two and how one rises while the other falls or stays the same. I tried to put together for the most part topics that were similar and would show an interesting relation to one another. I also looked up historical events or the times that certain Holmes stories were published to further analyze what was happening in the graph.

Murder v.s. Investigation

Screenshot (3)  While looking at the spike of investigation at around 1891 I started to search for murders around 1891. Although I came up short I did realize that Jack the Ripper, a killer who stabbed at least five prostitutes and mutilated four in London, was never really identified although they had several suspects they couldn’t pin point it to one man. While reading about this it came to me that investigation could be at a peak because from 1888 till about 1892 they were investigating and trying to identify this killer. Another chilling discovery was Johann Otto Hoch who was a German con man who claimed up to 50 victims possibly more. I also think he could be the reason investigation spiked because from 1888 till about 1891 he couldn’t be found then he was and in 1906 he was hanged. I believe the reason while investigation and murder correlate so well is that when murder occurs investigation peaks because they are trying to find the murderer, but when murder peaks investigation slowly rises because it is just beginning. This link shows Jack the Ripper as well as Johann Otto Hoch and what I was describing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_serial_killers_before_1900.

Divorce v.s. Religion

Screenshot (7)

I searched very rigorously to find any correlation with religion and divorce online, but what I did find was that divorce rates in England increased and decreased, but not drastically, and stayed in the same range for the most part.http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2010/jan/28/divorce-rates-marriage-ons is the link I used to find the divorce rates. What I could theorize is, some people that were married by the time they reached their thirties which was about the age you divorced found that they had different religious ideals than their husband. Another theory is that around this time period money could of been an issue with the end of world war one, and peoples husbands either dying or have become disable now are falling on tough times and need money or will simply divorce their husband.

Performance v.s. Schedule

Screenshot (8)

I didn’t know how two relate the two other than when you watch a performance you put it in your schedule but when I dove deeper into what could be the relation between the two I saw so much more. What noticed was that when I went to England recently I noticed that the theater district in the west end was so elaborate with many different shows and as I dove deeper I realized England has been doing theater since the 1700’s. In this link it shows all theater shows form the 1700’s to 2010 in England: http://www.guidetomusicaltheatre.com/london_shows_chronology/1700s-on.html. I also realized that at the peak of the scheduling line (in the graph) it was in 1893. The Holmes story the resident patient came out and it deals with a lot of scheduling jargon which could also be why scheduling peaked around that time. http://www.angelfire.com/ks/landzastanza/publication.html.

House v.s. Description

Screenshot (9)

While reading through some of the Sherlock Holmes stories I noticed that a lot of descriptions relate to house hold items or are in a house which correlated to the rises on the house line in the graph. I also put together that the reason these are so close together on the graph is because they go hand in hand.

Travel v.s. Job

Screenshot (10)

While looking at this graph I noticed that travel peaks a lot. The reason I think it goes up is because a lot of people in England have to travel to get anywhere whether it be taking the tube, or a carriage. While I was in London I noticed everything revolved around transportation which could be the reason for the peak. Also transportation and jobs go hand in hand because in order to get to your job you need to take some mode of transportation.

 

Topic Modeling Part Deux

The ten topics I originally chose were crime, love, money, face words, “chillin’ like Sherlock” (my strangely-named topic for words like pipe, sat, fire, smoke, silence, and bachelor), male descriptive words, detective words, investigation, sailing, and death. The following graphs show how some of these topics relate and, in exceptional cases, reveal interesting correlations with historical events that took place at the time when the stories in which they appear were printed, which I found really intriguing to delve into and analyze.

Detective/Investigation

Chart 1

These topics seemed similar enough. Ironically, however, trends appeared somewhat sporadic throughout, though there was a strong correlation roughly from 1909 to late 1911, with a significant peak in early 1911. This correlates most strongly with the release of The Red Circle (http://sherlockian.net/), though I couldn’t find any historical relevance.

Crime/Death

Chart 4

These topics, clearly connected through the crime of murder, showed a close trend in March 1922, the time of release of Thor Bridge (http://www.sherlockian.net/). In this story, the crime is, of course, murder (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Problem_of_Thor_Bridge#Plot_summary). No related historical events were found.

Sherlock/Male

Chart 2

Yet again, these topics seemed to make sense together, but trends were very sporadic. There was, however, a directly correlated peak in March 1923, the time of release for The Creeping Man (http://www.sherlockian.net/), which makes perfect sense for obvious reasons. No direct historical relation was found.

Money/Sailing

Chart 3

Figuring sailing and money were both tied to trade, I decided to look for trends between these two topics. Interestingly enough, “sailing” peaked in March 1904, then dipped in April 1904, at which time “money” spiked. In April 1904, the Entente cordiale was signed (http://www.branchcollective.org/), which established peace between France and England, likely opening up trade between the two, which makes sense with the spike in money-related words. The cause of decline in sailing-related words at this time, however, still remains unclear (or possibly unrelated).

Love/Face

Chart 5

Figuring these words might be related through the written portrayal of how people respond to the people they love (with regard to facial expressions, at least), I thought it might be worth comparing the trends between the two. Sure enough, they peaked together in March 1922 and January 1924. March 1922 was the time of release for Thor Bridge (http://sherlockian.net/), which seems to be sort of a fluke in terms of trying to explain the relation to the prominence of these topics. January 1924, however, was when The Sussex Vampire was released (http://sherlockian.net/). This story, featuring a child as the culprit (http://sherlockian.net/), in conjunction with the obvious implications in its name, seems to fit the bill for a story that would predictably feature frequent mention of the topics of love and things having to do with the face. I was not, however, able to find any direct historical relation to the prominence of either topic.

Topic Modeling Part 2

The ten topics I initially chose were: crime, case solving, observation, economy, body, morning/night, appearance, passing of time, written documents, and setting.

sh topic model chart 1

First, I decided to compare the topics of crime and case solving. There seemed to be a dramatic increase in the appearance of crime from 1894 to 1904. Upon looking back at the topic index, I found that the largest prevalence of crime was in The Adventure of the Second Stain, which was published in late 1904. Indeed, a decade after the original Adventures appeared in The Strand, a series of others were published known as The Return of Sherlock Holmes. The appearance of both crime and case solving varied throughout 1904, and while dipping over or under each other, they remained close until 1927.

Continue reading

Topic Modeling Analysis

From these topic modeling graphs, trends in the Sherlock Holmes stories as well as the real world can be seen.  It is safe to say that this was the popular culture back in the late 1800s/early 1900s just from seeing the themes within the story.  I thought it was interesting to find the relationships with real world events.

Screen Shot 2015-04-03 at 2.08.40 PM

The first chart shows “crime”, “crime scene”, “murder”, “family and relationships” and “investigation”.  There are a couple of large spikes for family and relationships, especially in the 1920s, although a quick google search leaves me empty handed.  Crime also shows a spike in the early 1920s as well, and this could be because of The Red Scare, which was not exclusive to the United States.  During this several high profile cases in the United States such as, Sacco and Vanzetti as well as the Scopes Monkey Trial have occurred. By this time, news sources in Great Britain would have got word of these cases. The other three topics are very related to crime in itself.

Screen Shot 2015-04-03 at 2.02.08 PM

With the next chart, which shows “finance” and “foreign affairs”, there is one large spike for foreign affairs on September 1st, 1917.  The Great War was still going on, and this was the year the United States entered the war.  Also, Germany has declared unrestrictive submarine warfare several months earlier.  Russia’s position in the war was being questioned as Bolsheviks started to gain more control in Russia, starting with the abdication of Tsar Nicholas II in March of 1917 as well as continuing riots in the country.  Finance unfortunately does not receive the same attention that foreign affairs has been receiving.

Screen Shot 2015-04-03 at 2.57.56 PM

With the last chart, dealing with “smoking”, “residential streets” and “transportation”.  A large spike in residential streets is seen on January 1st, 1904.  In this year, road infrastructure is still in its infancy, roads were still poorly made, cars were not as widespread and modern traffic laws have not been drafted yet.  What is quite strange is that transportation does not see as large of a spike even in 1908 when the Ford Motor Company introduced the Model T, which has quickly become the most popular car around the world, beating British brands such as Austin, Rolls-Royce and Bentley.

Historical Interrelation: Words and War

 

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle penned all the Sherlock Holmes stories between 1891 and 1927, creating a literary legend that would not soon be forgotten. By using topic modeling techniques and some fancy algorithms, we can investigate the potential relevance of word usage in his stories.

The Great War was a momentous event that almost exactly bisected Doyles’ creations, so I will view my ten topics through this lens. I found an interesting website for historical background on London during this time period, which helped me to identify significant events.

Estate vs Business

Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 2.39.52 PM

In contrasting estate and business, I noticed a spike in the former before 1905 and again before 1910. This could have been because British colonies had large tea estates in India. However, estate crashed back down after 1910 and business led throughout the rest of the time period. It is possible that the industrial growth of London led to this change, and both words are lower during the war and flu pandemic of 1918.

Search vs Case

Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 2.40.18 PM

Regarding search and case, there is a slight rise in each during the war years. Once again, the flu of 1918 and the peak of both words during the 1910-1920 decade may involve correlation rather than causation. The term search may also have increased during the war because soldiers could be missing in action.

Crime vs Reasoning 

Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 2.41.01 PM

Reasoning was mentioned more than crime prior to 1915, but the use of crime skyrocketed after this, calming back down in the 1920’s. This fits well with the suffrage movement and trade unions growing, as this disrupted established society. From the 20th century London website:

The suffragettes, the Irish ‘Home Rule’ movement and trade unions all agitated for change, sometimes with violence. In 1918 some political demands were met through the Representation of the People Act, which gave the vote to working men and women over 30.

Appearance vs Expression

Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 2.41.19 PM

Appearance quite possibly became less important than expression after the war, due to the realities it forced upon the people of London. This trend continued through the 20’s, as the growth of jazz may have led to expression becoming more common.

Silent Reflection vs Public

Screen Shot 2015-04-01 at 2.41.36 PM

Silent reflection had an interesting spike in 1908, and it dropped precipitously, becoming equal to public by 1914. It is possible that the Alien Act impacted this word usage, as many immigrants tried to come to London during this period. Perhaps many Londoners had thoughts about the impact on their society, but the war decreased their time for such thoughts.

While I am not certain about these linguistic developments, I feel topic modeling could be an important tool to help scholars revisit the past, specifically helpful in distinguishing how history affects word usage.