Our group dealt with “This is Just to Say,” where six of the original words of the poem were replaced at random by the madlib engine. The language of this poem is fairly straightforward, and the content of the poem is essentially three statements: declaration, apology, and description. So, in reading the poems generated, the reader attempts to draw some logical connection between unrelated sentiments.
It is difficult to draw meaning from the randomly generated poems, as there is no unifying theme between the new words generated. Even some of the individual statements in the poem, out of context from the rest of the content, lack grammatical correctness. This is because of the variable nature found within the nuances of verbs, adjectives, and nouns. Nouns can refer to tangible things, as well as sentiments; likewise, adjectives can describe qualities which make no sense, and verbs can become muddled when the object and subject of them is not clearly defined.
In experimenting with the madlibs engine, the meaning behind the words of the poem, and words in general, slowly start to break down. Similarly to how repeating a word will turn it into meaningless sound, repeating the same structure of the poem, albeit with various words switched around, slowly makes the structure and content of the poem lose all meaning. This random rewording of the poem makes me appreciate just carefully chosen the words in the poem are, despite their simplistic nature. In fact, despite the generated poems generally having zero meaning, those which contained simpler vocabulary came closer to having some coherent form.